Comments on Michael Jacovides’ Paper “Hume and the Rotting Turnip”

Authors

  • Stanley Tweyman Department of Humanities, York University

Keywords:

Rotting Turnip, Design Argument, atheist sceptic, dogmatist, extreme consequent scepticism

Abstract

In Part 12 of David Hume’s, Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion, Professor Jacovides attempts to explain how the Rotting Turnip explains the generation of life; and who the various characters mentioned in this Part–Philo, Cleanthes, Demea, the atheist, the theist, dogmatists, sceptics–actually represent. In my paper, I show that the Rotting Turnip cannot explain the generation of life, and that Jacovides’ attempt to identify which (actual) philosophers hold what positions in the Dialogues does not shed any light on the structure of this work, and the philosophic roles that the speakers–particularly Cleanthes and Philo–play in reaching the final dictum articulated by Philo in the penultimate paragraph in Part 12.

Downloads

Published

2025-01-18

How to Cite

Comments on Michael Jacovides’ Paper “Hume and the Rotting Turnip”. (2025). Humanities Bulletin, 7(2), 68-71. https://staging.journals.lapub.co.uk/index.php/HB/article/view/2909

Similar Articles

1-10 of 26

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.

Most read articles by the same author(s)